2021-11-08Linux: Off the Pedestal

Another Sudden Epiphany in the Autumn of 2021: Linux Is for Playing With, Not for Using

Fragments of reflection from Little Monk Says, copied together into this article:
  • As a veteran Linux user, let me say today: the Linux system is truly damn bizarre, way too weird! Swap out a graphics card and you can no longer get into the desktop, forcing you to face a black screen head-on and explore commands. My Linux desktop, used for six years without interruption, piled with applications and personal data — am I really supposed to reinstall the system from scratch all over again?! Even the tty console will not let a person rest easy: it repeatedly and automatically switches back to tty1, simply refusing to let you type commands in tty2–tty6 — so high and mighty. It looks like this thing needs one graphics card to wait on it for its whole life, or it will turn on you. What is the use of it? Garbage!
  • After years of fiddling with the Linux desktop, I feel it is low-end: few desktop features, prone to crashing, and above all short on software — the critical software all depends on Windows, and the best little utilities all require Wine. Now all development has been migrated back to Windows; as for that Linux box, let it gather dust. Lesson: don't tinker with fringe stuff.
  • I have seen through it: the only thing playable about the Linux desktop is the Linux desktop itself. Previously, on my manjaro desktop system, I often opened a Windows virtual machine and large numbers of Wine applications; I have now decided not to treat it as a productivity platform anymore — I will just use it to fiddle with niche window managers and put together the sort of eye candy you see in unixporn desktop screenshots, and that is that. The time once allocated to it was 99%; the time now allocated to it is 1%.
  • Only after many years did I learn that the primary significance of the Linux desktop is looking cool. If you genuinely want to accomplish something serious, the Linux desktop will not do; you still have to turn to VirtualBox and Windows. If software under Windows averages a score of 100, then Linux can only score 61.5 — quite a wide gap. Not enough software, and the software's functions not powerful enough either — so what real point is there in using a Linux desktop system? One can only treat it as a special kind of game to play now and then.
  • Is there any software under Linux that costs more than 500 dollars a copy? Very few, I suppose! And that shows one thing — professional software is far too scarce! The professional industry software all lives in Windows. When a person is using Linux, he still has to open a Windows virtual machine to run professional industry software — that is nothing but a tasteless chicken rib of an arrangement.
  • On the Deepin forum I discovered an interesting thread; the OP is 72 years old and still playing with deepin linux, and he laments that even slightly professional software, such as stock-trading software, simply cannot run. Today's Linux desktop systems — only the desktop environment and its related software (office, entertainment, audio-video, images) has entered the beta stage; the various somewhat more professional applications that need to match it (stock trading, accounting, ERP, logistics, warehouse management, POS checkout, vocabulary learning for less common languages, and so on) are almost nowhere to be seen.
  • In the days of not screwing around with Linux and only using Windows, life is awfully idle. No problems, and hence no tricks and no discoveries, and this blog has gone to seed. Playing the game of "Linux desktop" is pure recreation; and when the game was over, I found that plenty of work still had to be done in a VirtualBox Windows virtual machine...
  • 18 Responses

    1. admin says:
      Just to clarify: the Linux referred to on this site mainly means the well-known Linux desktop operating system that claims to rival Microsoft Windows, not the systems used on servers. If you want to get any real productivity done on the desktop, you'd better give up on Linux!
      • M. says:
        Wonder if it works in reverse…… 'If you want to run a server, Windows Server is not recommended.'
        • yk00365 says:
          It does not hold. winserver has the advantage of being simple and easy to maintain. To name just one thing: the Liaoning personnel exam uses Alibaba Cloud winserver with IIS to serve an aspx registration page — it is just registration, collecting information, displaying exam scores — why would you need a complicated LAMP for that? And easy maintenance suits temporary web pages better.
    2. xiaobai says:
      Even I, a computer-illiterate mechanical engineering student, actually read it with great relish. Quite interesting.
    3. Leovinci says:
      Haven't used Windows for almost ten years — switched to Mac. Linux mainly for cloud servers.
    4. Leovinci says:
      Haven't used Windows for almost ten years — switched to Mac. Linux mainly for cloud servers.
    5. jack says:
      Desktop Linux — every single one of them is garbage... Do a bit of tidying up, or don't even bother tinkering at all, and you never know which time it'll spring a Surprise on you -_ || The server side really is hassle-free (keep GUIs at arm's length).
      • admin says:
        Right. The Linux desktop isn't for getting things done. Only the desktop environments and their related software (office, entertainment, video/audio, graphics) have entered the beta stage.
    6. Mr. Cookie says:
      To be honest, the only Linux work that counts as productivity is the sort programmers do. Want to run CAD? OpenCAD? Want to do graphic design? GIMP? For 3D modeling, are you really supposed to go learn OpenSCAD? Fortunately there's still DaVinci Resolve for video. Set servers aside, and Linux genuinely can't be called productive. The silver lining is that in recent years the web has, to some extent, propped up Linux along with ChromeOS — but with the internet environment here in China? Taobao's web version offers no experience worth speaking of at all.
    7. HIMWLWDSJ says:
      I use Arch + i3 daily and it actually feels fine Maybe it's because all I normally do is play some Minecraft and write some C
    8. 5waker says:
      For ordinary users I really don't recommend Linux — stick honestly with Windows, save yourself the worry and effort. If you have real needs, then go for Linux, but even with real needs I'd still recommend setting up a dual boot; at the very least, when Linux crashes you still have an OS to use.
      • admin says:
        Your answer is very constructive — treating the operating system honestly as a productivity tool is truly smart and down-to-earth. The dictator of the Firefox community is a perfect negative example: things were going fine, then suddenly some version killed off all the add-ons, sending Firefox back to the Paleolithic overnight and leaving developers and users dumbfounded.
    9. Ya says:
      This piece, along with the one on the Emacs editor, is excellently said. Bottom line: everything is a tool. Tools are there to make things convenient for people, not to hold people hostage. Use whatever works; no philosophy of suffering. These things are toys for people with time on their hands. And if after all the playing around it turns out better than Windows — then just keep using it.
    10. M. says:
      There is a better option now: windows subsystem for linux You will have absolutely no reason to install Linux separately on your computer anymore — just use WSL to install whichever Linux distro you need.
    11. rice says:
      Exactly — you have got to be practical, got to be realistic. Of course there is nothing wrong with playing around either: keep using it if it is good, toss it if it is not.
    12. rice says:
      Practicality is what is real; everything else is empty.

    Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *